The movie is a docudrama set most of the time in Edgar’s office, where your sight is immediately attracted by the fascinating use of lights and shadows . The camera changes continuously perspective and contributes in making this film incredibly realistic.
“J. Edgar” directed by Clint Eastwood looks inside the complex life of one of the most popular directors of the FBI by focusing on his anger, greediness and on his fragilities.
Mr. Hoover is represented in the movie as a thoughtful, angry and solitary man. A man who adored and was very close to his family, especially to his mum, a strict and conservative woman who never accepted her son’s feelings for Clyde Tolson, close collaborator. Edgar’s mother definitely influenced his way of thinking and acting and made him believe that power and success were the only aims in life. This made Edgar constantly suffer inside and never made him truly accept himself. All the anger was then addressed to the people he was in contact with.
Hoover’s arrogance was a direct consequence of his individualistic moral code, of his personal ambitions and of his selfishness. John Edgar is constantly figured as an arrogant megalomaniac, who never really fought and worked to serve the country, but to become an idol and to create a perfect image of himself. In fact, there was no way somebody could’ve made him realize that the actual facts were always different from his stories and narrations. He was full of bitter and hate towards everyone (especially communists and black civil rights activists) except his really close collaborators, which served him for almost 50 years.
At last, the brave and severe chief appeared to have two different lives. The public life was the one in which he appeared brave, honest and surrounded by loyal and courageous companions. In fact, we must not forget he was the author of the arrests of Ku Klux Klan members, of the authors of the violent Bolshevik rebellions in the U.S.A and of some of the most well known gangsters of those years. Although he maintained a weird and suspect attitude during the investigations on the murder of Kennedy, he was admired by many Americans for the way he innovated and strengthened the Bureau. He was also a suspect for the murders of Martin Luther King and Malcolm X. Instead, during his private life he outdrew his most sensible side, his weaknesses and fragilities. The docudrama digs into his secret and repressed love story, into his concerns that devour him.
I strongly recommend the vision of the movie “J.Edgar”, for it’s ability to look inside a complex American figure who ruled his country for half-century. Disdain and compassion are the perfect combination transmitted by an authentic director such as Clint Eastwood. Furthermore, the story contained some unique soliloquies that rendered the narration almost didactic. The liberal glance at the homosexual relation and at the power of love in all its forms will surely renovate your current opinions and thoughts.